Last Updated on 17th April 2023 by Caroline Haye
Another chapter in my henna story
Despite my long history of widespread vitiligo, I consider myself lucky in that I have never developed much white hair. But I eventually started to grey naturally in those areas that most people eventually do. In other words, around the temples and at the front hairline… Which may or may not have something to do with carrying the vitiligo gene. Either way, I have been searching for some time now for the best vitiligo hair colour to use to cover up depigmented hair.
Not everyone (whether they have vitiligo or not) wants to hide their greys. But many of us do, hence my search. In particular I have been looking for the best hair dye to cover white hair without causing allergies or inflammation that can aggravate vitiligo.
Life is unfair
It’s no secret that life can be unfair. It is a well known fact that some men start to look distinguished with a few flecks of silver in their mane. (That is, if they are lucky enough not to go bald first.) And some women also manage to carry off that stately, elegant look that can result from strands of platinum streaking artistically through their coiffure.
I, on the other hand, do not belong to that happy group of people who grey gracefully. In fact, I belong to that other group that just looks tired, like a drab and faded shadow of their former self! As a result, the past couple of decades have found me either sitting in the salon on a regular basis, having my head plastered with an evil-smelling concoction of hazardous chemicals, or reaching for equally noxious over-the-counter dyes every time those white roots threatened to make a re-appearance.
It wasn’t until a gradual increase in scalp irritation prompted me to read up on the ingredients contained in commercial hair dyes (even in most of the so-called “natural” hair colourants) that I realised what I was doing to my already vitiligo-susceptible skin amounted to madness. Repeatedly dying my hair was exposing my scalp, and my entire system, to an unacceptable and unnecessary toxic load. And it might cause more of my hair to lose natural pigment by aggravating vitiligo. So I vowed never to go anywhere near chemical dyes again. Which is how I came to try pure henna powder as a safe and non-irritant alternative.
My first experience of henna had pros & cons
Safe, non-irritating but messy to use and less than perfect grey coverage
At the time of writing this, I had been using henna bricks from Lush for a couple of years and been relatively happy with the results. From the moment I stopped using chemical dyes I had absolutely no more scalp irritation whatsoever. Better still, I had peace of mind, knowing that colouring my hair was no longer bringing me into contact with any substances that might trigger new areas of vitiligo.
Compared to these benefits, the fact that the grey coverage was not always 100% and the process of applying pure henna was time consuming and very, very messy seemed unimportant and well worth the trade-off. But I have to admit that the palaver of melting and mixing the henna with water in a Bain Marie on the stove, until it was just the right consistency, was a bit of a chore. Trying to get the gritty mixture to cover every individual strand of hair – especially the problem white ones – was tricky and messy too. I then used to have to leave the henna on for nearly 3 hours to stand a chance of getting a dark enough shade on the greys. And, then rinsing it off was a bit like trying to wash clods of dried mud out of my hair, to say nothing of the mess it left behind in the shower.
So my next discovery came as a welcome relief and something of a godsend to me. This was the Surya Brasil range of henna and other hair care products. It was free from virtually all the nasty chemicals usually found in hair products, but proved to be quick and easy to use at home, giving my hair superior colour, shine and grey coverage, even compared to the professional salon permanent colours I used to use.
My next henna discovery
Surya Brasil Henna Cream shades as applied to grey hair
I found this range when I was researching natural products for inclusion in Vitiligo Store. I was a bit skeptical at first because all the products I had found previously that claimed to be “more natural” than salon dyes whilst delivering similar results did not stand up to scrutiny. These were usually marginally better than most hair dyes, in that they did not contain ammonia and boasted a bunch of natural sounding plant extracts, but they still contained hydrogen peroxide (which is the very last thing anyone with vitiligo needs to apply to their skin) and Paraphenylenediamine (PPD: the same chemical as used for dying fabrics and carpets – and the main cause, in hair colourants, of irritation, allergic reaction and even, occasionally, anaphylactic attacks). So I had more or less given up on finding anything that would improve on the slightly disappointing performance of pure henna without compromising on safety. But then I came across Surya Brasil.
I was delighted with the ease of use and the lovely results from using this henna product. But the main thing for me was that it allowed me to continue to use an alternative, henna-based hair colour that significantly reduced the risk of aggravating my vitiligo. I have, since first publishing this post, moved on to other alternatives in my quest for the perfect vitiligo hair dye solution and you can read about these in 2 Chemical-Free Ways to Colour Your Vitiligo Hair.
12 thoughts on “Best vitiligo hair colour”
I used to dye my hair every 6-8 weeks and my vitiligo started around the same time.
I feel obliged to mention i have previously been diagnosed with bladder cancer, which has been associated with hydrogen peroxide, ammonia PPD use in hair dyes. I would strongly urge any vitiligo patients to reconsider use of any hair dyes. Even if they do not contain PPD they need a similar ingredient to activate the oxidation process to change the hair colour. i have also read there is association of cancer with PPD.
There is a new product available that will temporarily change grey hair back to the original colour, and just needs to be reapplied regularly. it was discovered by a biologist but unfortunately only works if you are natural brunette (not blonde or red).
I also desperately miss dyeing my hair esp since i have extensive vitiligo i would like to feel like i could improve my appearance, but bladder cancer is a horrible, painful scary disease, that will never be discussed in any magazine because the hair dye advertisements fund its production.
So sorry to hear about your cancer, Erin. I hope that you have made a good recovery. I can certainly understand your caution over hair dyes (and every other potentially carcinogenic products, come to that) after having such a horrible experience. I was interested to read what you wrote about that new product and am doing a bit of research on it. I will post any useful information about that on my blog. Thanks for the feedback. Be well 🙂
How to use surya henna cream
How to use surya henna cream..? If we use cream , shampoo and conditioner then it will long last?
Hello! I too had though henna might be a good alternative for us with vitiligo, but I found this study that shows that henna naturally contains three chemicals which are the same ones that cause vitiligo in commercial dyes: PPD, p-aminophenol, and m-aminophenol. See Table 6 in this study:
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cod.12074/full
I’m glad you raised this, Michelle, because you have quite rightly highlighted the dangers of thinking that all henna products are 100% natural when, in fact, that is very far from the truth. There are a lot of so-called “natural” henna products and other commercial henna preparations on the market that have the chemicals you refer to added to them to make them into permanent dyes. These are the categories of product referred to in table 6 of the article.
PPD, p-aminophenol and m-aminophenol do not occur naturally in henna but are among the additives in such products.
This is why I am a big fan of genuinely pure henna (like the bricks from Lush) and also the gentle semi-permanent products (like my favourite – Surya Henna Cream) which are highly unlikely to cause any adverse skin reactions because they do not have the chemicals listed in table 6 of the study added to them.
That said, there are never any guarantees when it comes to skin sensitivities, so a patch test is always advisable when using any hair colourant, no matter how natural it is.
It’s very simple to apply, Preet – almost like normal permanent dyes really. You wash your hair first (preferably using the Surya Brasil shampoo) but don’t apply any conditioner. You then part the hair into sections and apply the cream with your fingers (wearing gloves) or a brush paying special attention to the roots. Then you work more product into the full length of the hair and put on the loose plastic cap. Then you leave it on for the length of time indicated on the chart according to your chosen colour. For hair that has lost its pigment it is worth leaving it on for 30 minutes or so longer to make sure you get good coverage.
After rinsing out the colour (till the water runs clear) you apply the Surya Brasil conditioner to help keep the colour longer. I also like to use their leave-in conditioner too, especially to protect the colour from the effects of the sun.
As it is a semi-permanent colour it will wash out eventually but, as long as you don’t wash your hair every day, it should last you a good few weeks.
I used Surya Brasil for a month on my beard. Unfortunately, my experience with it was pretty bad. It’s too messy, stains the skin and had to be re-applied every two days. Vitiligo hair seems too resistant to any hair dye products which don’t contain harsh chemicals.
Hi,
thank you for all the info and your effort. I have a question regarding the Surya product, which as far as I read seems to be quite friendly for people with vitiligo. So, I am thinking of using this for dyeing two small areas of my beard (very short trimmed), which are now white, while the rest of the beard is properly black. Do you know if I can apply it somehow to those small areas, or it can work only for the hair?
Kay
Have you tried Swiss O-Par? It’s made to dye eyelashes and brows but can be used on other facial hair as well. Does not contain hydrogen peroxide or coal tar.
That’s an interesting question, Kay. Sadly, I think I would have to advise against this. The instructions say “Do not apply on the eyelashes, eyebrows or upper lip.” Admittedly, it does not mention the chin and this area does have less sensitive skin than the eye areas and upper lip. But the skin on the face in general is more sensitive than on the scalp.
Sorry to hear that, Torsten but thanks for sharing this information. It may be that beard hair is more resistant than head hair.